Skip to main content

To Etch or Not To Etch?


Regarde, before thee, a photo of two beads. To etch or not to etch, that is the question. I really like the organic quality of the etched bead (the second one), but I also really like the colors that you can see with the unetched bead (the first one). So, my question to thee - to etch or not to etch?

Two things - 1) I apologize for the quality of the photo. While I can somewhat take pictures now, it doesn't mean I can process them. I guess I need to take Photography for Dummies. 2) I am not asking whether you like the actual beads; I realize that question would be one of taste. I am just asking which one you prefer!!!

Thank you!

Edited to add: to see the beads better, you may have to click on the photo to make it bigger. This is my fault - the photo is ok, but like I said, the processing leaves something to be desired! It is hard to see the difference, but the first one is shinier than the second!

Comments

Preserve Jewelry Studio said…
I regret to mention that I can't see the difference in the photo. I am sure there is a difference, but it is not obvious to the untrained eye.
August 31, 2009 at 7:35 PM
Marie Cramp said…
I love them both. I would do some of each. The sparkle in the first is really lovely and the earthiness of the second is rustic and fun. BTW I love the colours too ;) They are really great beads. I hate not having any money, I swear I must have had half those rainbow sets in my cart. lol. next time I hope.

Marie
August 31, 2009 at 7:46 PM
Lorelei Eurto said…
Hey Sue!
These are beautiful!
I like the etched bead better!
August 31, 2009 at 8:01 PM
Unknown said…
These beads are gorgeous! My first choice would be etched as I generally like a matt finish with autumn colors (and a glossy with wintery icy blues). I definitely need a pair of these.
August 31, 2009 at 8:47 PM
SummersStudio said…
Sue, I love both of these for their very autumn colours. I have a slight, very slight, preference for the etched one. It has a subtleness that is very appealing to me.
August 31, 2009 at 10:18 PM
Anonymous said…
they are both beautiful and each would work for a specific look. i personally like the finish of the etched bead.
August 31, 2009 at 10:26 PM
Cindy said…
Very nice beads...the colors are fantastic for Fall! I like them either way..but would agree that I'd have a preference for the etched too.
Cindy
www.sweetbeadstudio.com
August 31, 2009 at 11:17 PM
Katie said…
I love the etched bead - it looks more organic and like it's some beautiful rock formation that youcaptured in the bead.
September 1, 2009 at 12:17 AM
stregata said…
First - the colours on these beads are just lovely and they remind me of terrazzo. Although I generally prefer etched beads (I just love the matte surface), I think this bead is gorgeous in glossy.
September 1, 2009 at 12:26 AM
Unknown said…
I prefer the etched one, brings out the colours better in my opinion. Very nice, earthy looking beads either way tho =D

Emi
September 1, 2009 at 9:37 AM
LLYYNN - Lynn Davis said…
Etch, definitely etch. But I'm a shoo-in for the matte look. I love them both, don't get me wrong. But I always favor the etched ones.

Beauties!
September 1, 2009 at 10:10 AM
Laura Sparling said…
Etched. Normally I'm a glossy bead kinda gal, but those are candidiates for the acid bath!

Great beads. :o)
September 1, 2009 at 11:34 AM
Silver Parrot said…
I like the non-etched version best. The colors are so muted anyway - I like the "kick" provided by the shine of the un-etched glass. They are beautiful either way, though.
September 1, 2009 at 2:47 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bead Soup Blog Party!

Welcome to the 3rd Bead Soup Blog Party! What is a Bead Soup Blog Party? Each beader was paired up with another jewelry designer and tasked with sending the following: ~ A focal ~ A special clasp (not just a lobster claw) ~ Some coordinating spacers or beads Using the focal and the clasp was mandatory, but we could use anything from our own stash to round out the rest, and choose to use the coordinating beads or not. You may recall my partner was Margot Potter ; click this link to see the blog post I wrote of what she sent me! Here's what I made! Dangly earrings! Come see what the rest of us made! 1. Lori Anderson, Pretty Things 2. Kitty Durmaj, Perles and Life 3. Michelle Heim, Life In the Bead Lane 4. Lisa Petrillo, Lucid Moon Studio 5. Anitra Gordy, Leelu Creations 6. Paige Maxim, Paige Maxim Designs 7. Marianna Boylan, Pretty Shiny Things 8. Cheryl Roe, BeadRoe 9. Heidi Post, Ex Post Facto 10. Cindy Wimmer, Sweet Bead Studio 11. Terri Gauthier, Blooming Ideas 12. ...
102 comments
Read more

Bead Soup Blog Party!

Today is the day of the big Bead Soup Blog Party reveal! Lori Anderson, the wonderful host of this event, reported that there are 362 participants this year! That's a lot of blogs to look at. I will try my best to get to each and every one, but it may take weeks! My partner was Laura Zeiner from Stick Lizard Designs . She has a lot of talent, that girl. If you recall in my previous post , she sent me these beads: And this is what I made: I love love love the focal she sent me. It's gorgeous! The lack of sun here in Pittsburgh does nothing for this rock! The colors and crystals are beautiful! I had no idea what to do with it, though, and I pondered for quite a while. I decided to make links with 18 gauge copper wire and think I did an ok job at it. I'm sure there are some better ways to do this, and I'd love to hear about them. I'm just really starting to get into the world of wire and so my skills aren't that great. In any event, I made some beady links ...
65 comments
Read more

The Tacky Earring Blog Hop

Diana Ptaszynski had a great idea, instead of a Tacky Christmas Sweater blog hop, a Tacky Holiday Earring blog hop! I was on it.  I had ideas right away.  I had so many I had to control myself.  You can buy these for $15 each, too!  Here we go! I found these awesome wreaths in the miniature Christmas section in Michaels, and they go perfectly with silver and copper colored plastic beads! These trees were found in Michaels, on an end-cap - I assume they are scrapbook or card making supplies, but make fantastic earrings.  The holes were a little small and far down, so I had to make LARGE loops.  Paired these with cute little gold colored jingle bells! And, finally, the ones I had in my head the moment she announced the blog hop.  Dr. Seuss sparkly puff balls with ribbons.  The only thing that would have made these better for me is if I could have found the red ribbons I really wanted to pair these with - don't get me wrong, the silver is ...
11 comments
Read more